
Is Now Really the Time to Send Missionaries?
The November 3 midterms were a bloodbath for Republicans. Democrats took both houses of Congress.1 Pennsylvania, where I live, is headed toward single-party rule, Virginia voters wrote abortion and same-sex marriage into their state constitution, and the results in places such as Texas and Michigan suggest that some of the cultural victories conservatives were celebrating a year ago may not be nearly as durable as they seemed.
Many factors explain what happened, from economics to foreign policy to candidate quality, and so it would be a mistake to read this election as a direct referendum on Christian morality. Even so, Christians cannot ignore what these results say about the cultural climate, since they raise an uncomfortable question: What if the purported “vibe shift” of the last two years was an illusion?
Perhaps it was wishful thinking to suppose that America was drifting back toward a society friendlier to Christianity. If so, the consequences reach beyond American politics to the Great Commission itself, and a second, harder question follows from the first: Is now really the time to send missionaries? If our churches and communities are in serious trouble domestically, can they realistically keep sending workers around the world at the same pace?
The simple reality is that the modern missions movement is only as strong as the churches that send it, and so the work of rebuilding the church at home cannot be separated from the work of reaching the nations abroad. We must grapple with what this election reveals about the culture in which American churches now labor, what missions history shows about the home base every sending movement has required, and what Scripture teaches about the kind of church fit to reproduce itself.
What follows are four hard truths drawn from those sources, two honest objections to them, and, finally, a direct answer to the question—and what to do next.
1. The vibe shift was a reprieve, not a revival.
The first truth concerns the culture in which American churches must now do their work, and a useful guide to it is Aaron Renn, who has written extensively about what he calls the three worlds of evangelicalism.2 Renn argues that American Christianity has passed through three broad cultural eras. In the positive world, being a Christian was generally seen as a good thing, since the faith carried social prestige and its morality was assumed to be normative. Then came the neutral world, roughly the mid-1990s through 2014, when Christianity became one option among many and being a Christian was neither necessarily an advantage nor automatically a disadvantage. Finally, beginning around 2014, on the eve of Obergefell, the country entered the negative world, in which historic Christian beliefs are viewed with suspicion, especially by the institutions that shape public life, and traditional moral convictions are treated as obstacles to progress.
For a time, the tide seemed to be turning. Young men were said to be rediscovering Christianity, as in large part they still are; public figures spoke more openly about God; some of the taboos around traditional Christian convictions seemed to weaken; and after the 2024 election there was a sense in some circles that the country was becoming hospitable to the faith again, moving back toward the neutral world or even, as some suggested, toward a new positive one. I was encouraged by some of that myself, but there is now reason to doubt that the underlying culture changed much at all, and the clearest evidence is the list of those who won.
In Texas, James Talarico defeated Ken Paxton, becoming the first Democrat to win statewide office there in more than 30 years.3 Talarico is a Presbyterian seminarian who regularly invokes his professed Christian faith while defending abortion and progressive sexual ethics, positions that the church has condemned throughout her history. Whatever one calls that religion, it is not the faith once delivered to the saints; it is heretical progressivism dressed in borrowed vestments, quoting Scripture in order to bless what Scripture forbids. And that such a message could carry Texas, of all places, says a great deal about how thin the nation’s Christian consensus has worn. In Michigan, meanwhile, voters elected Abdul El-Sayed, who will become the first Muslim to serve in the U.S. Senate.4 In Pennsylvania, Democrats reelected Gov. Josh Shapiro, held the state House, and flipped the state Senate.5 And Virginia’s three new amendments establish a right to abortion, remove the state’s ban on same-sex marriage, and restore voting rights after incarceration.6
A political victory can create breathing room, shaping policy in ways that either free or hinder the church in her work, but it does not mean that the church is growing healthier, that her neighbors are becoming more truly Christian, or that the institutions shaping society have recovered a Christian moral framework. If anything, this month’s results suggest that Renn’s analysis still stands and that the vibe shift was a reprieve rather than a revival. That conclusion has implications for how Christians lead their churches, raise their families, and educate their children, and it bears directly on the question at hand, because missionaries have never been sent from nowhere.
2. Every missionary movement has had a home base.
Every missionary movement has depended on a home base strong enough to sustain it, and the modern Protestant movement is the classic case. In 1792, William Carey published his Enquiry, arguing that Christians had an obligation to use ordinary means, like prayer and evangelism, to bring the gospel to the nations.7 That same year the Baptist Missionary Society was formed on the then-revolutionary conviction that God would use those who go to spread the gospel. Carey faced resistance, and the England of his day was hardly a model, marked as it was by spiritual decline, poverty, political turmoil, and religious compromise.
Yet British society retained a substantial Christian presence of churches, schools, publishers, pastors, and networks of believers with the freedom to organize, raise money, and send workers overseas, so that Carey, who neither financed nor sustained the movement by himself, was in some ways running on the fumes of Christendom. A whole network back home, including pastor Andrew Fuller, supplied the theological, organizational, and financial support necessary to keep the work going. Missions history is often told as the story of a few extraordinary individuals, but behind them stood churches with enough strength and stability to hold the rope and not let go.
The same pattern has held wherever missionary sending has flourished since. Over the last several decades, South Korea became one of the most significant missionary-sending countries in the world as the Korean church grew and built the institutions, theological training, financial resources, and networks needed to send people abroad, and Brazil followed a similar path. By 2020, Brazil and South Korea ranked second and third among missionary-sending countries, behind only the United States.8 In both cases it was expanding churches that developed the capacity to support an international movement, and the converse is proving equally true. South Korea’s missionary movement has begun to plateau as the Korean church contends with population decline, secularization, falling participation among younger generations, and an aging missionary workforce; according to the Korea World Missions Association, the number of long-term Korean missionaries declined to 21,621 in 2024.9 The number remains impressive, but the trend illustrates the rule that as sending churches weaken, the sending movement eventually feels it.
American Christians must take that rule seriously, because many have spent decades assuming that American evangelicalism would automatically keep supplying missionaries, money, theological resources, and ministry infrastructure to the rest of the world. Suppose instead that American churches struggle to disciple their own children, that biblical illiteracy spreads and congregations shrink, that the average churchgoer tithes but has little margin for generosity, and that the surrounding culture becomes so hostile that churches are mostly in survival mode. Where, then, will the next generation of missionaries come from, who will support them, and what sort of Christianity will America export if its own churches are becoming doctrinally confused and spiritually unhealthy?
3. Healthy churches reproduce. Sick ones cannot (and should not).
That last question leads to the third truth, which is that the capacity to send depends on the health of the church and not merely on her size or wealth. In the natural world, reproduction is a sign of maturity, for a developed organism can produce and sustain new life, and the analogy holds for the church: healthy churches plant churches, mature disciples make disciples, and established congregations send workers into new places. The church is, of course, more than a biological organism. Scripture calls her the body of Christ, and God can do extraordinary things through congregations that are poor, small, or beleaguered. Ordinarily, however, a church struggling merely to survive will have a harder time sustaining a large missionary effort than one that is doctrinally sound, financially stable, and spiritually fruitful, and it would be unwise to assume that sending programs can keep expanding indefinitely while the ailments at home go untreated.
Nor is health only a matter of capacity, for it also determines what is sent. Consider Paul’s charge to Timothy: “what you have heard from me in the presence of many witnesses entrust to faithful men, who will be able to teach others also” (2 Tim. 2:2). That is multiplication through faithful transmission, but it begins with something faithfully received and preserved. If churches are not teaching the faith accurately, discipling the next generation, and raising up qualified leaders, what exactly are they multiplying? A church that has lost confidence in the Word of God, abandoned biblical morality, or forgotten its responsibility to make disciples is not in a position to reproduce itself anywhere else, nor should it, because what the nations need from America is not more churches of that kind but churches worth multiplying.
4. The home front needs more of our energy—and yet the nations still need some of it too.
The fourth truth follows from the first three and concerns priorities. If the culture has not turned, if sending has always depended on a strong home base, and if only healthy churches are worth multiplying, then America itself demands enormous attention at present. Churches need revitalizing in the big cities and, perhaps especially, in rural areas, and communities without a faithful gospel witness need new ones. Pastors must be trained, families strengthened, and children catechized by fathers and mothers who understand their responsibility to raise them “in the discipline and instruction of the Lord” (Eph. 6:4). The church must recover confidence in the ordinary means of grace, which are preaching, prayer, baptism, and the Lord’s Supper, and congregations must be willing to uphold the Bible’s teaching about life, marriage, and sexuality even when doing so comes at a social cost, as it surely will.
This is a heavier task than it was a generation ago because the negative world requires a different kind of preparation than the positive world did. When Christianity enjoys broad cultural respect, the church can build on moral assumptions her neighbors already share. When those assumptions disappear, she must do more of the work herself, and Christians must build churches and households that can sustain Christian conviction while the culture actively works against them. All of that takes time, money, and people, which is why, in my opinion, the majority of the American church’s energy should go toward strengthening and rebuilding the church at home, with a portion set aside for international missions and church planting beyond America’s borders. The precise proportion is open to dispute; the point is that both must be done at once, in appropriate degrees.
The nations cannot be abandoned in the process of winning back our own home, since the Great Commission has not expired, and brothers and sisters overseas depend on faithful partnerships with churches here. Nor are the two tasks rivals. The work at home serves the work abroad, since a strengthened local church is the kind of congregation that may one day send missionaries, a trained pastor strengthens a potential sending church, and some of the children discipled today may eventually be called to serve Christ overseas.
What a season of rebuilding does require is that the share devoted to the nations be spent where it accomplishes the most, and that is the strongest argument for indigenous missions. Alongside sending workers, one of the best things American churches can do for the sake of the nations is to strengthen faithful national churches and partner with believers already ministering in their own countries, who often know the language, culture, customs, and religious environment in ways a foreign missionary may spend years trying to learn and who can serve in places Western missionaries would have difficulty going. That is one reason to commend the work of groups like Live Global, part of the ABWE family of ministries.10 Rather than establishing ministries overseas and controlling them from North America, Live Global takes a national-first approach, coming alongside indigenous leaders already doing the work in their own cultural contexts.
None of this is an argument against sending Western missionaries where they are needed. Places with no healthy indigenous church, and people groups with no access to the gospel, still need cross-cultural workers to bring it. But the center of gravity of global Christianity has shifted away from the West, which is no longer the only major source of missionaries, and in many cases its greatest contribution may be equipping faithful Christians from other nations who are better positioned than Westerners to reach their own peoples and their neighbors. That matters all the more if the American church is entering a prolonged season of institutional weakness, and it accords with the goal of missions, which was never to make the rest of the world permanently dependent on America but to see healthy churches among all peoples that become senders themselves.
Answering Two Objections
1. “But Jesus did not say to fix your own country first.”
That is true. The Great Commission binds the church regardless of political conditions (Matt. 28:19), and America’s problems are no excuse to retreat from the nations. But Scripture also teaches that believers have particular obligations to the people God has placed closest to them, so that loves and responsibilities must be properly ordered, and duties toward family, church, neighbor, and nation do not disappear because there are spiritual needs elsewhere. Paul instructs believers to “do good to everyone, and especially to those who are of the household of faith” (Gal. 6:10), and he warns that anyone who “does not provide for his relatives, and especially for members of his household, … has denied the faith and is worse than an unbeliever” (1 Tim. 5:8). Those passages are not about missionary strategy, but they do establish a principle about the moral weight of one’s nearest obligations.
The principle applies at every level. A pastor cannot neglect the congregation God entrusted to him because he is preoccupied with opportunities elsewhere, parents cannot neglect their own children while congratulating themselves for supporting Christian work overseas, and churches cannot assume that funding missions programs excuses them from the hard work of maintaining their own spiritual vitality. The Great Commission still applies, but it is carried out through actual churches with real limitations, resources, and obligations, and those churches must exercise wisdom.
2. “But the early church spread the gospel under persecution.”
It did, and that is an important qualification. In Acts 8, persecution broke out against the church in Jerusalem, and “those who were scattered went about preaching the word” (Acts 8:4). God used the opposition they faced to spread the gospel, and Christians have carried it through wars, revolutions, imprisonment, and intense suffering ever since. The church does not need political power or cultural favor to obey Christ, for God is sovereign and can accomplish his purposes under any circumstances.
But a distinction must be drawn between the extraordinary ways God advances the gospel through suffering and the ordinary structures through which churches sustain missionary work over generations. A church can grow under persecution and even send missionaries, yet persecution is not good for every part of the church’s institutional life, since seminaries, training, missionary support, and international partnerships ordinarily require resources, planning, and a degree of stability. Persecution should therefore not be romanticized, nor should Christians grow fatalistic about decline in the West. The negative world may be the present reality, but that is no reason to accept the weakening of the church passively, and believers who labor to build strong churches and institutions, strengthen their families, preserve the faith, and create conditions in which the next generation can flourish do so in part so that the missionary movement may continue.
So What Should We Do?
The practical conclusion follows the order of the argument: health first, and sending out of health. Pastors, for instance, should look first to the spiritual health of their own congregations, preaching the Word faithfully, training qualified elders, discipling their people, strengthening families, and preparing the young to remain faithful in a culture that may increasingly oppose them. Then, as God gives a church strength and maturity, its leaders should consider seriously whom to send, whether to plant a church in the next town or to an unreached people group across the world, and whom to support among indigenous church planters and pastors already on the ground. Sending should grow out of congregational health.
Those not in vocational ministry should ask how they can contribute to rebuilding the church where they are. It is easy to bewail the state of society and harder to be faithful in a local church, where faithfulness means raising children in the faith, supporting pastors, and taking responsibility for evangelizing neighbors. That work may seem less glorious than service overseas, but a healthy church in Pennsylvania, or Texas, or Virginia can become a source of gospel witness to its own community and far beyond. At the same time, those with the means to support indigenous Christian workers or missionaries overseas, or to help a missionary family reach the field, should do so. And if God is calling you, do not suppress that desire.
To return, then, to the question with which this article began: Is now really the time to send missionaries? Yes. But American Christians must be far more serious about the condition of the churches doing the sending, for they cannot assume that America will remain a strong sending nation if American Christianity keeps weakening, or that the resources, freedoms, and institutions they inherited will always be there, and they certainly cannot assume that a temporary political victory solved the deeper spiritual problems facing the land. If Aaron Renn is right, and I think he is, the church now lives in the negative world and may remain there for some time. That means rebuilding strong churches, strong families, and strong institutions, with a serious commitment to discipling the next generation, and as we rebuild, we keep sending qualified workers, keep supporting faithful indigenous churches, and keep praying that God will raise up missionaries from every nation to reach every nation. But the order matters, because if we want a healthy missionary movement tomorrow, we need healthy sending churches today.
Elections and vibe shifts come and go. Our confidence is in Christ, who promised, “I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it” (Matt. 16:18). He has given us work to do at home and among the nations, and may he make us faithful in both.
Notes
1. Associated Press, Democrats win the House and Senate in the 2026 midterms. Published November 3, 2026.
2. Aaron Renn, The Three Worlds of Evangelicalism Debate; What Caused the Negative World? Renn dates the emergence of the negative world to approximately 2014. Reading the recent vibe shift through his framework is this article’s application, not a claim that Renn has declared a return to the neutral world.
3. Associated Press, James Talarico wins Texas U.S. Senate election; CBS News election coverage. The characterization of Talarico’s theology is the author’s assessment, not a news organization’s conclusion.
4. Associated Press, Abdul El-Sayed wins Michigan Senate race. November 3, 2026.
5. Spotlight PA, Pennsylvania Election Results; PoliticsPA, It’s a Democratic Trifecta.
6. Virginia Mercury, Election Results and Constitutional Amendments; Virginia Department of Elections, Official Amendment Language; Axios Richmond, Amendment Results. The abortion amendment permits third-trimester regulation with specified exceptions. The approved amendments face applicable certification and legal processes.
7. Boston University, William Carey: History of Missiology; William Carey Center, An Enquiry (1792).
8. Christianity Today, Lausanne Report: Most Missionaries Are Reaching the Reached; IMB, Global Senders Commit to Be Stronger Together. Rankings use World Christian Database 2020 figures and may differ from individual national missionary-agency reports.
9. Korea World Missions Association, 2024 Missionary Statistics; Christianity Today, South Korea’s Missions Success Won’t Be Its Future. The KWMA counts 21,621 Korean long-term missionaries in 2024; broader datasets use different definitions.
10. Live Global, About and Missions Philosophy; ABWE, National Partnerships; Live Global, National Partnerships.
Discover more from Alex Kocman
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
